Evaluation

I have been working on my transgender project for the whole of third year. I feel the work has really grown and developed in it’s way of expressing questions of identity and performance. By working on issues of gender through my final year, including my dissertation – I feel I have been able to fully submerge myself and get a deeper understanding on issues of identity and gender.

Miss Transgender UK was a good way of gaining insight into a part of the transgender community.  It allowed me to meet people and network for future projects.

I developed my business skills through this module – I gained experience with publishing articles and images. Learning a  lot about how to deal with ownership, copyright and negotiating what I wanted from the papers/ magazines etc.

Interviewing and talking to trans people from different backgrounds has widened my understanding  of the complexities behind gender and its connections to other parts of peoples’ lives. I found recorded interviews very helpful and in the future I will try and do this as much as possible. Before Chris – I would take notes, which is distracting when in conversation with somebody – when recording, it allows you to concentrate on the person in front of you.

It was thought that for my final piece I would create a large body of portraits that people could respond to. The four accompanying portraits is a small example of this. However as discussed with Anthony this can turn into a long term project – whereby I can travel over Britain over the next 12 – 24 months, and hopefully have the outcome of an exhibition. Hopefully I will connect with more transgender people,and develop more individual stories through photography for exhibition.

I am really pleased that I decided to explore video and sound, which is a new area for me – it gave me a new passion and curosity in my own work from a technical angle. I think the progression into video and sound came from my desire to work with multi-media and really wanting the voice of the subject matter to be projected across the photography.  From the point of view of communicating the issues I have been exploring, I wanted to take my work further than the classic form of documentation I had created so far. Below is a paragraph from my conclusion on ‘What is Real’ in January –

“I feel as if these past few months have scratched a surface in terms of questioning the representation of gender and the effects of this on individuals. Moving forward I want to DECONSTRUCT our preconceptions and classifications!”

I think focusing on the gaze was an integral part to this project. The gaze has an important part in the photograph and also in terms of trans issues. As mentioned before – gender has been associated with gaze, fetishising people, voyeurism and these are all aspects connected to the  photographic / male (patriarchal) gaze. The moving portrait was a powerful way of highlighting ideas of control (subject matter vs camera vs audience) – the power of the gaze – as discussed in dijkstras essay and throughout my blog. Using Chris’s and Jennifer’s voice echoes what I attempt to portray when people write on their portraits. Literally giving the subject matter a direction over the tone and theme to the video, which is also emphasised by the music.
The bare , raw aesthetics of the subject matter were chosen to try and highlight the fact we are all individual and unique – that there was some honesty between the camera and the subject matter and what is to be portrayed to the audience. If Jennifer had her make up on for example, this could create a different feeling and focus the video in a different manner – also this is same with Chris and his clothes.

In terms of exhibiting my videos – I see it as a fine art installation, an open space where people can analyse and consider the issues surrounding the portraits. In a strange way, I feel the moving portraits are a mirror – not showing the viewer what is in front of them, but more so addressing viewers perceptions of gender, image and identity. Below are some sketches for ideas of layout design. The first sketch is a fairly traditional idea, the second I thought it may be strong to have two large boxes which the audience could walk into, becoming submerged in the moving portrait – almost as if they have walked into someone else stream of consciousness.

I would like these moving portraits to be exhibited for the International trans day of visibility on the 20th November – I would see it as fitting -(with companion portraits such as the four I have included in this module.)  My work is about celebrating identity and gender – to acknowledge that asking questions and being curious is natural and OK but also to respect and acknowledge all humans – include those who do not ‘fit’ with peoples’ ideas of ‘normal’.

“Despite the illusion of giving understanding, what seeing through photographs really invites is an acquisitive relation to the world that nourishes aesthetic awareness and promotes emotional detachment.” 
― Susan SontagOn Photography

The above quote from Sontag can be seen to be very true within photography. But I think to be aware of the issues of photography, tourist photography as Sontag once stated is important in what type of photography you create.  To truly understand a subject, a person, an area you need to take time, patience and a lot of listening. And I think this project will become stronger with time.The plans over the summer is to work in a much more collaborative manner with the likes of for example, Chris and other people I am in connection with. This last module has made me recognise the uses of photography and it’s place in a wider discussion, I am looking forward to using other tools, other mediums in relation to my photography to enhance the content, human presence and factual information.

I am looking forward to the future of my project and where else it will go.

Portfolio Box –

Set of four prints
(two small prints to keep safe)
USB stick with FINAL Moving Portrait videos. Word document with link to this blog. Links to .jpg files for four portraits.

 

 

 

 

Final Moving Portraits

Please find original videos and premier files on USB.

Untitled Moving Portraits

This body of work is inspired by exploring the binary approach to gender our society has lived in for so long. Yet life is not as simple as on or off – it is a constant stream of energy which sometimes, cannot be defined through words alone. This body of work explores the foundations of identity which are solidified in illusion, performance and hidden behind masks. These videos document the stories of a trans man, Chris Hubley and a trans woman, Jennifer Green. You could argue they are a work of fiction created through the thoughts and lives of these two individuals.  A stream of consciousness based on memory, transition, loss and growth,  which connects each and every one of us – regardless of what is on the surface.

 

Additional Portraits

Here is a very small example of portraits I took of Jennifer when we created the moving portrait in the studio. I used the digital medium format camera and the quality and sharpness is superb. The Greg image has a vignette which the Jennifer image does not have. I placed these images together and have managed to cut out and edit the background to make it even. In terms of using these images, I think I may use them for the end of year exhibition at university.

It makes me think of a passport photo – and feels like a very literal questioning of Jennifer’s identity and where the place for Greg is in her life as well as Jennifer. How does she present herself to the world – which one to choose?

together

 

 

Moving Portrait no. 2

Image and  music – voice to come next week.

I have spent the whole day creating the music – it did not come as easy as Jennifer’s soundscape , which I created in about an hour. This on the other hand, has taken me six hours, for all its simplicity – I have added, stripped back, added and stripped back. At first I tried to mimick a tune incredibly similar to Jennifer’s, which did not work with Chris’ visual. Though the feeling of the music is quite similar – using the stratosphere wind through this soundscape as well as Jennifer’s I feel it has its own identity.

Tomorrow, Chris will come over and we are going to record the voice , for the final part to this video. I then need to adjust small details like the intro and end for both Chris’ and Jennifer’s moving portrait.

I am still undecided whether to submit Jennifer as a single outcome to this project or use Jennifer and Chris as a series.

Matching the two pieces

Screen Shot 2016-05-06 at 22.39.33

Tonight Chris came round and we did the piece again with a canon 60d camera like I did with Jennifer. I am happier with the result. However, due to the environment it was obviously not the same result as with Jennifer in the studio. In the studio I used a large over head soft box, could pull the subject matter far away from the back drop and have my camera at a longer distance from the subject matter – all together creating a piece which has a great dispersion and control of light.
I filmed Chris in my tiny flat – where he was much closer to the back drop and the camera was much closer to him. Therefore the highlights and the shadows are much harsher, furthermore the LED light, though putting it on top of the kitchen table could not be placed in the same way the soft box was used in the studio.
Unfortunately Chris cannot make it to Cheltenham due to work, but I would love to take him into the studio to create the same outcome as Jennifer.

Screen Shot 2016-05-06 at 22.47.42
However, what I did do, was try and compliment and connect the two pieces together and it slightly reminded me of an article about colour palettes that Wes Anderson uses (as above).

Screen Shot 2016-05-06 at 22.56.55Screen Shot 2016-05-06 at 22.56.48

Below is a screenshot from where I put the two piece against each other on a white background – with the music/text overlaying.  The colour edit/grade on Chris is slightly different to the one I did above, I prefer the first edit personally. The second edit below is slightly dark and has a pink tone.

I think because I had such a vision for this one powerful video – I feel by having two, it detracts from the intensity. I am going to talk to my tutors on Monday, and see what their opinion and advice on the matter is.

Screen Shot 2016-05-07 at 00.18.22

 

Chris Hubley Video

For my final piece I have created a moving portrait with Jennifer. To accompany this it was decided that I could create the same portrait but with a trans man – Chris Hubley.
Tonight I filmed Chris and also interviewed him. I am happy with the interview – I now have around 40 minutes of footage I can use as research and inspiration to create text for the voice over. I am very laid back in terms of my direction of questioning and responses in my interview with Chris – I do not know him very well, so I think with little prompts, it was just good to see what he wanted to open to.

However, I am really dissapointed with the video quality – The 60d I hired out did not have a battery in it so I could not use it. The only equipment created a really low grade quality image, which I am not happy with. I am seeing Chris on Thursday so I have emailed him to see if he is happy to re- do the shoot, hopefully with a higher grade camera.
Also, because I am unable to get Chris to the studios in Cheltenham, I am not going to be able to recreate the same background/studio control I had with Jennifer. For that reason, I think I am going to film Chris on my balcony – with the sky as a backdrop – weather permitting.

I really hope this works out, even if it does not get completed for my hand in next week, I still would like to achieve and create this moving portrait with Chris.

Developments on film


Untitled Moving Portrait
This moving portrait is part of an ongoing project exploring the foundations of identity which are solidified in illusion, performance and hidden behind masks. In some sense it is a work of fiction created by myself, based on the thoughts and life of Jennifer Green; Yet deals with concepts of memory and transition, each of us experience everyday of our lives.

__________________________________________________________

I am really happy with the way the text connects with the image and music… I have made the voice slightly quieter than one might expect, because I just want to create that idea of unconscious / personal thoughts. The music I created, I feel supports the intense gaze and atmosphere of the visual.

After talking Anthony and Andy, I am going to try and create a second video like this with Chris. Chris and I are already developing an idea of a film – which incorporates my photography and his artwork. I have just received a reply of Chris saying his is happy to create this second film on Tuesday night, but I am having difficulty hiring out equipment at the moment.

Screen Shot 2016-04-29 at 09.21.57
It will be good if it goes ahead, to get the two sides of being a trans woman and a trans man, I am aware there are many other forms of gender and identities but this will still be a good set.

Andy and Anthony suggested leaving a longer pause at the end before Jennifer’s portrait fades out. But I think the way the face imprints in the back of your eyelids at the same time as the last chord is played as everything fades out has a strong effect.

I am creating a page below about Jennifer for my website:

http://www.jessieedwardsthomas.co.uk/identityproject

.